What does stability in residential care mean? Part I

Feb 2020

Written by Jenna Bolllinger

Stability…can be defined as children’s feelings of connectedness and belonging that are characterised by steady emotional attachments to adults and members of peer networks

Devaney, McGregor and Moran 2019, p. 635

After four years working in residential care, both on the floor and as a clinician, I wanted to better understand what stability really means for young people in residential care? Can stability be achieved in residential care? And, if so, can it be reparative and healing?

My PhD research set out to answer these questions. Over the past three years, I’ve spent time speaking with residential workers and young people across New South Wales to better understand what stability means to them. I interviewed 13 staff members from various agencies, including floor staff, house managers, upper management and clinicians. I also interviewed eight young residential care leavers, aged between 18 and 24, who had had varying amounts of stability within their placements. The young people had been in residential care for between one and eight years, with a range of placement experiences.

In this first blog, I want to share what I’ve found in the research and through discussions with young people about the meaning and experience of stability in residential care.

What does the research tell us about stability in residential care?

When we think about the word ‘stability’, we probably have a sense that we know what that means. Offering a definition might be more challenging though, like defining the words ‘because’ or ‘love’. It is a word we implicitly understand, but struggle to define. The challenge with being unable to define a word is that it is hard to challenge the status quo of what it means. According to the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (AIHW, 2018) stability for young people in out-of-home care (OOHC) means one or two placements. This means they have been in the one or two placements their entire time in OOHC. And for a large number of children and young people in OOHC, this probably is stable. They know who they live with, they know they will continue to live there, they identify as part of that family. Therefore, they are stable within that placement but do they feel connected and a sense of belonging to their family? There seem to be some pieces missing from the official definition of stability.

As workers in residential care, many of us know one or two placements may not actually mean that the young person feels connected to the family. They may not identify as part of the family or feel they are accepted as part of the family. They may not have a sense they can continue to live there, particularly if they have been told they cannot stay there once they turn 18 and age out of care.

We also know that if a young person is in residential care it is likely that they will not have had one or two foster placements, but a great number. The young people I interviewed, for instance, had experienced a range of placements from none prior to entering residential care to 32 foster care placements before entering residential care. While in residential care, they experienced from one placement to 28 placements. So, the highest number of total placements for one young person was 36, with the smallest number being two total placements.

The AIHW’s notion of stability is almost out of reach for most young people in residential care on the day they enter. But does this mean that stability is actually out of reach?

 

What does stability mean for young people in residential care?

Stability, according to the AIHW is a maximum of two placements over the course of a child’s life in OOHC. This is essentially how it has been operationalised in the literature. For example, Unrau (2007) completed a review of 43 studies, over multiple countries, into foster care stability and found that it was measured in a number of different ways, but always with the theme of few placements = stable, many placements = unstable. The review considered papers from the UK (n = 7), Europe (n = 3), Australia (n = 7) and the US and Canada (n = 26) completed between 1959 and 2004. Globally, stability is measured as placements-over-time with a series of outcome variables that identify whether more placements lead to worse outcomes. Spoiler alert: they do (generally).

To date, no research has examined this issue specifically in residential care. There are multiple additional layers and moving parts in residential care that make stability particularly challenging to determine. While one could implement a placements-over-time paradigm to mark stability this would be missing many pieces of the puzzle. For example, one young person I interviewed only had two placements (therefore ‘stable’), however, the first placement ended abruptly while the young person was in the hospital. The second placement was a one-to-one placement, so no other young people resided there, but the roster was almost exclusively staffed with casuals and this particular young person had no idea who would be on shift each day.

Another young person experienced only one residential care placement (therefore stable) but developed no connection to the staff or young people. This young person shared that there was no emotional involvement or connection with the staff. The staff stayed in the office for the entirety of their shifts and seemed to approach their job as being primarily about risk management (i.e.to ensure no-one physically harmed each other). This young person also had a very large number of foster care placements prior to entering residential care.

If stability is to be measured as placements-over-time, invariably a key component of what makes a young person feel stable will be missed. Some of the key components of ‘stability’ for young people who have lived in residential care were;

  1. feeling safe,
  2. having consistent staff and,
  3. having a consistent period of time in a placement.

In their words, these dynamics were described as:

Feeling safe

I believe that- yes OK there are a lot of children in care. I understand that. But putting two young people together who obviously are not going to be able to live with each other or anything like that as they are going to assault each other all the time or whatever the case may be… That in itself needs to be looked at a little bit.

24 years of age, female

Consistent Staff

Like when [they] don’t have to change. So you get to know one worker and they get to stay. It’s good because you know them, especially if you liked them. l used to hate having to get like new ones

19 years of age, female

… the only people you could really build a connection with were the permanent staff and you know, it was almost like you were forced to build a decent relationship with them because they were there all the time.

18 years of age, male

Time in Placement

Young people mentioned the need for time in placement, that is, for the placement to have enough duration to build a sense of connection and a sense the placement wouldn’t end prematurely:

If you want a child to be familiar as such and not act out don’t move them hours away from the placement to where they were, you know, don’t move them because they’re moving away from schools, not just schools that they have made friends, they have made friends in that area and when you’re pulling them away they have got to start again and that mentally disturbs a young person because their life is just jumbled.

T, 24, female

Concluding thought

Stability is not really about the number the placements, but the experience of consistency, predictability and a sense of safety. So far, though, this has not been looked at in residential care by researchers. In essence, time in a placement is a necessary but not sufficient condition for stability: young people need much more than that.

In Part II of this blog series on stability, I will explore whether stability can be achieved in residential care.

Jenna Bollinger
Psychologist (B. Psych Hons, M. Psych For) and PhD researcher at Monash University

 

References

Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (2018). Child Protection Australia 2016-17. AIHW, Canberra.

Barber, J.G., & Delfabbro, P.H. (2003). Placement stability and the psychosocial well-beng of children in foster care. Research on Social Work Practice, 13(4), 415-431.

O’Neill, M., Risley-Curtiss, C., Ayòn, C., & Rankin Williams, L. (2012). Placement stability in the context of child development. Children and Youth Services Review, 34, 1251-1258.

Unrau, Y.A. (2007). Research on placement moves: Seeking the perspective of foster children. Children and Youth Services Review, 29, 122-137.

You may be interested in: Residential care

Creating positive social climates and home-like environments in therapeutic care - Practice guide
Creating positive social climates and home-like environments in therapeutic care - Practice guide
This guide has been developed to support the implementation of Essential Element: Physical Environments from the Ten Essential Elements of Therapeutic Care. It explores how to create therapeutic care contexts...
Read more
Putting theory into practice
Putting theory into practice
Sometimes you might wonder why you need to learn about theory. I have heard people say:   Residential work with young people is often conducted amidst high anxiety, uncertainty and...
Read more
Stability in residential Care: Part II
Stability in residential Care: Part II
Sarah is 14 and has been in placement for 18 months. She lives in a residential house with two boys and one girl. The boys display aggressive behaviours and are...
Read more
8 ways to support young people in residential care during COVID-19
8 ways to support young people in residential care during COVID-19
How do we keep to the therapeutic care principles of safety, consistency, predictability, and routine in a world that feels like it has turned upside down overnight? It’s near impossible!...
Read more
How do we create excellence in Intensive Therapeutic residential care practice?
How do we create excellence in Intensive Therapeutic residential care practice?
What creates high quality therapeutic residential care? This is the question often asked of agencies, of staff, of policy makers and of the young people themselves. There is no simple...
Read more
Cultivating curiosity in Therapeutic residential care
Cultivating curiosity in Therapeutic residential care
Curiosity is something that has excited me my whole life. I am sure a lot of you share my fascination and enthusiasm for curiosity. There seems to be wide support...
Read more
Therapeutic residential workers? Who are we?
Therapeutic residential workers? Who are we?
This blog is to introduce my recent research with therapeutic residential workers. Further blogs and practice guides relating to finding, keeping, acknowledging and celebrating the best person for the job...
Read more
10 ways to enable young people's participation in therapeutic residential care
10 ways to enable young people's participation in therapeutic residential care
In this blog, I’m keen to offer practitioners in therapeutic residential care some ideas about how to involve young people in decisions that affect their lives. Many young people in...
Read more
The Intensive Therapeutic Care dance
The Intensive Therapeutic Care dance
Therapeutic residential work can be conceptualised as a dance. It works best when therapeutic workers display therapeutic presence, are in sync with the young person, can making meaning of the...
Read more
Understanding and supporting young people who self-harm in residential care
Understanding and supporting young people who self-harm in residential care
Some of the young people we care for in the ITC programs deal with emotional distress and pain by hurting themselves physically. Young people hurting themselves is distressing to them...
Read more
What are the needs of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children and young people in care? Research brief
What are the needs of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children and young people in care? Research brief
Indigenous children and young people face unique challenges in the child welfare system. The dimensions of this problem are complex and multifaceted. Providing culturally safe and traumainformed therapeutic care to...
Read more
‘Tis the Season to be Jolly’ – but not for everyone
‘Tis the Season to be Jolly’ – but not for everyone
It’s all too easy to get wrapped up in the fun and happiness of Christmas and forget that, for others, the season isn’t necessarily a joyful one. For some the...
Read more
The 10 essential elements of Intensive Therapeutic Care NSW - Practice guide
The 10 essential elements of Intensive Therapeutic Care NSW - Practice guide
This guide has been developed to describe the 10 Essential Elements that form the basis for Intensive Therapeutic Care (ITC) service provision in NSW. The 10 Essential Elements have been...
Read more
What makes a good therapeutic residential care worker? Practice guide
What makes a good therapeutic residential care worker? Practice guide
Trained staff and consistent rostering are essential elements of therapeutic residential care. The purpose of this guide is to consider more broadly what makes an excellent therapeutic residential care worker...
Read more
How do you prepare for the transitioning of young people into an Intensive Therapeutic Care house? Part 2
How do you prepare for the transitioning of young people into an Intensive Therapeutic Care house? Part 2
In the first part of the Blog, we explored limit and expectation setting, maintaining a state of occupancy and the planning process for a successful transition. In part two of...
Read more
How do you prepare for the transitioning of young people into an Intensive Therapeutic Care house? Part 1
How do you prepare for the transitioning of young people into an Intensive Therapeutic Care house? Part 1
This is a two-part blog and will focus on the transition of young people into an Intensive Therapeutic Care house; however, most of the content is transferrable to other placement...
Read more
Changing your practice to being trauma informed in therapeutic residential care
Changing your practice to being trauma informed in therapeutic residential care
Whilst the following Arabian proverb takes a bit to get your head around it leads rather nicely into this blog and our brief introduction on the relevance of the conscious...
Read more
How to thrive in lock down, lean into what works in therapeutic care
How to thrive in lock down, lean into what works in therapeutic care
Lockdown means we lose touch with many things: friends, family, freedom. For young people, therapeutic youth workers and other staff in Intensive Therapeutic Care, however, it also offers an opportunity...
Read more
Trauma-informed relationship-based recovery reflection tool - Practice tool
Trauma-informed relationship-based recovery reflection tool - Practice tool
Children and young people need adults who can co-regulate with them and teach them about feelings and their inner world. This Trauma Informed Relationship-Based Recovery Reflection tool can be used...
Read more
Client mix and client matching in therapeutic care - Practice guide
Client mix and client matching in therapeutic care - Practice guide
Client mix and the process of client matching is one of the 10 Essential Elements underpinning the Intensive Therapeutic Care (ITC) system in New South Wales. This guide has been...
Read more
Trauma-informed care - Research brief
Trauma-informed care - Research brief
This research briefing aims to define and clarify what trauma, complex trauma and trauma informed care are. Extensive literature has now surmised that exposure to adverse experiences such as child...
Read more
Q&A with the trainer: Harmful sexual behaviour
Q&A with the trainer: Harmful sexual behaviour
Working with young people who engage in harmful sexual behaviour is complex and challenging. Cyra Fernandes and Dan Howell have spent over a 1000 hours in the past year helping carers and professionals...
Read more
Strengthening connections & relationships project
Strengthening connections & relationships project
What is this research about? Young people in residential care face major challenges that can prevent them from forming healthy relationships and a strong personal identity, which are critical building...
Read more
Come on it’s only a game
Come on it’s only a game
Many of you will have experienced something like the following… A residential worker is observing two young people playing table tennis in the rear yard of the residential unit. One...
Read more
Do ‘no touch’ policies in residential care keep workers and children safe? It’s not that simple
Do ‘no touch’ policies in residential care keep workers and children safe? It’s not that simple
Lyn was 16 and had grown up in foster and residential care. Lyn was interviewed about her experience and views about out of home care. She was extremely positive about...
Read more
What Was I Thinking? Handling the Amygdala Hijack
What Was I Thinking? Handling the Amygdala Hijack
Remember that time when you put the child you care for back to bed for the fourth time? Your thoughts suggested a level of desperation and wishful thinking, hoping that...
Read more
Christmas in residential care: It doesn’t need to be the most wonderful time of the year
Christmas in residential care: It doesn’t need to be the most wonderful time of the year
Christmas is a time of joy and celebration for many Australians, but it can also bring pressure and unrealistic expectations. The shops are decorated, Christmas songs are everywhere, and cheesy...
Read more
How are restrictive practices interpreted in therapeutic residential care?
How are restrictive practices interpreted in therapeutic residential care?
This blog article was written by Glenys Bristow,  Senior Specialist, Therapeutic Residential Care, CETC. Restrictive practice in therapeutic care The Royal Commision into Violence, Abuse and Exploitation of People with...
Read more
The most difficult thing about residential care work
The most difficult thing about residential care work
The most difficult aspect of working in residential care is not managing the behavioural challenges of the children and young people, the demanding shifts, or the lack of resources. Rather,...
Read more
Research Update: Understanding Relationships in Therapeutic Residential Care
Research Update: Understanding Relationships in Therapeutic Residential Care
The Centre for Excellence in Therapeutic Care (CETC) is engaged in ongoing research to understand how positive, trusting relationships and social connections can be fostered for young people in Therapeutic...
Read more
Meet the CareSouth team
Meet the CareSouth team
CareSouth was recently awarded the Outstanding Therapeutic Residential Care Team Award at Youth Action NSW's Youth Work Awards. The CETC proposed the new Outstanding Therapeutic Residential Care Team award category...
Read more
Christmas time when glad tidings of joy should abound, and love be with us all
Christmas time when glad tidings of joy should abound, and love be with us all
Christmas, for many, is an exciting time of year. However, for some children and young people, particularly those who have experienced attachment difficulties, trauma and/or adverse childhood events, Christmas can...
Read more
What is neuroaffirming practice and how can it help young people in out-of-home care?
What is neuroaffirming practice and how can it help young people in out-of-home care?
The 2nd of April is World Autism Awareness Day, celebrating and promoting understanding and inclusiveness of people on the autism spectrum. In out-of-home care, neurodiversity is a highly prevalent and...
Read more
The essential role of collaboration in clinical assessments for young people experiencing complex trauma
The essential role of collaboration in clinical assessments for young people experiencing complex trauma
As a clinician supporting young people who engage in harmful sexual behaviour, I have the privilege of travelling across the northern region of Victoria and engaging with many residential workers....
Read more
“I’m not a Barbie girl”: Spatial design reform in residential care
“I’m not a Barbie girl”: Spatial design reform in residential care
The Create Voices in Action conference was held in Adelaide in March 2024. Three compelling voices at the conference belonged to Professor Suzie Attiwill and Create Consultants Hayley and Ella.  ...
Read more