Adult and child - healing

Let’s be the generation that ends youth incarceration—and builds a justice system that truly puts children first

Jun 2025

Written by Noel Macnamara

In Australia today, the practice of incarcerating children—some as young as 10—continues to cast a long shadow over our justice system. Youth detention in Australia, particularly as it affects Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children, has reached crisis levels. Despite decades of evidence showing that detention causes more harm than good, Australia remains one of the few Western countries where children under the age of 14 can be imprisoned. It’s time to stop criminalising childhood.

Every year, hundreds of children are held in youth detention centres across the country. A disproportionate number are Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children. Although they make up around 6% of the youth population, they account for nearly 50% of those in detention on an average night. This is not a coincidence—it is a consequence of systemic racism, intergenerational trauma, poverty, and the ongoing impacts of colonisation.

Many of these children are detained not because they are dangerous, but because they are disadvantaged. Minor offences, unpaid fines, or simply not having access to safe housing and community support can lead to youth detention in Australia. In some cases, children are held on remand for long periods without being convicted, often because there is nowhere else for them to go. These are not just numbers—they are children who deserve safety, dignity and care.

The consequences of detention are lifelong. It increases the likelihood of reoffending, disconnects children from education, family and culture, and contributes to poor mental health and trauma. For Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children, the damage runs even deeper. It disrupts cultural connection, severs ties to Country, and continues cycles of removal that began with the Stolen Generations.

In 2021, the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child reiterated its call for Australia to raise the minimum age of criminal responsibility from 10 to at least 14. Medical, legal and child development experts across the country have echoed this recommendation, pointing to overwhelming evidence that early criminalisation harms children’s development and violates their rights. Yet despite these clear recommendations, most Australian states and territories have failed to take meaningful action to address the harms of youth detention in Australia.

There is hope—and it lies in the leadership of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities, who continue to advocate for change and for a system that puts children first.

I want to share the pledge led by the National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Legal Services (NATSILS). They need our support. I have signed it, and I encourage you to do so after watching the Town Hall recording linked below.

The pledge calls on us to:

  1. Stand against the ongoing criminalisation of childhood

  2. Support a movement for justice that puts the rights and wellbeing of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children first

  3. Uplift the voices and aspirations of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children, and centre the leadership of their communities

These are not radical demands. They are a call to recognise the humanity, potential and dignity of all children. They are a call to choose care over punishment, healing over harm, and justice over incarceration.

The movement to raise the age and reform youth justice is not just about policy—it’s about who we are and what we value as a society. Do we believe children deserve support and opportunity? Or do we accept a system that locks them away and compounds their harm?

It is in small acts of solidarity—signing a pledge, attending a forum, writing to our representatives—that we keep this issue visible. We can be part of a collective voice that refuses to look away, that demands better, and that amplifies the voices of those who’ve been silenced for too long.

We all have a role to play. Whether you’re a teacher, a parent, a carer, a youth worker, or simply someone who believes in fairness, you can be part of this movement. Start by listening. Learn about the history and reality of youth detention in Australia. Educate others. And most importantly—act.

The NATSILS pledge is a powerful starting point. By signing it, you stand in solidarity with children, families and communities calling for a better future. You affirm that no child should be defined by their worst moment—and that all children, no matter their background, deserve to grow up safe, supported and free.

Let’s be the generation that ends youth incarceration—and builds a justice system that truly puts children first.

You may be interested in: Youth justice

Care criminalisation: issues and current research - Research brief
Care criminalisation: issues and current research - Research brief
Young people who are in, or have been in out-of-home care, particularly those with experience of living in residential care, are vulnerable to a number of negative outcomes, including having...
Read more
They came to us for care and left with a criminal record
They came to us for care and left with a criminal record
There is a nexus between living in Out of Home Care (OOHC) and being involved with the criminal justice system. In NSW children and young people in OOHC have been...
Read more
Leaving Care: What we know and don’t know about outcomes for young people
Leaving Care: What we know and don’t know about outcomes for young people
The research is clear: young people do not fare well when they leave care. Study after study, both in Australia and internationally, tells us that our care leavers are more...
Read more
Minimum age of criminal responsibility in the ACT
Minimum age of criminal responsibility in the ACT
  This submission addresses the question of whether the age of criminal responsibility (MACR) should be increased and submits that the age should be raised from 10 years old to...
Read more
Let’s Talk About the Summer Holiday – a poem about detention
Let’s Talk About the Summer Holiday – a poem about detention
"Let’s talk about the summer holiday, even though I’m in detention in was still fun aye. Because it was so hot, there was no time to use the indoor gym...
Read more
Minimum Age of Criminal Responsibility - alternative diversion model
Minimum Age of Criminal Responsibility - alternative diversion model
The focus of this submission The Australian Childhood Foundation and Centre for Excellence in Therapeutic Care (CETC) are dedicated to upholding the rights of children and helping them to heal...
Read more
When systems designed to protect do harm
When systems designed to protect do harm
What comes to mind when you think about the child protection or youth justice system?  Protection and safeguarding? Rehabilitation? Trauma-informed care? These two complex and often interacting systems are intended...
Read more
Women in Leadership: Fiona Atkins at Ashley Youth Detention Centre
Women in Leadership: Fiona Atkins at Ashley Youth Detention Centre
The care of young people in detention has been a focus in the media both in Australia and overseas. Media reports have highlighted inadequate levels of care and abuse of...
Read more
Student spotlight: John Gallagher on Youth Justice
Student spotlight: John Gallagher on Youth Justice
Over the past year, the Centre for Excellence in Therapeutic Care has launched its first blended learning program, CHC40521 - Certificate IV in Youth Justice.Dan Howell, Senior Manager for Training,...
Read more
Tough talk, weak evidence: Victoria’s step backward on the minimum age
Tough talk, weak evidence: Victoria’s step backward on the minimum age
The Centre for Excellence in Therapeutic Care (CETC) is confounded, disappointed and seriously concerned about the Victorian Government’s backflip on raising the Minimum Age of Criminal Responsibility (MACR) in Victoria....
Read more
Trauma-informed... youth detention? The realities of reform
Trauma-informed... youth detention? The realities of reform
Last week, CETC facilitated an insightful panel about trauma-informed care and young people in youth detention. CETC welcomed Joanne O’Connor, Associate Professor Tim Moore and Murray Robinson to share their...
Read more
The overlooked crisis of FASD hiding in youth justice and out-of-home care
The overlooked crisis of FASD hiding in youth justice and out-of-home care
In Australia, children and young people with Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder (FASD) in out-of-home care are at critically greater risk of getting involved with the youth justice system. The issues...
Read more
Senate inquiry into Australia’s youth justice and incarceration system
Senate inquiry into Australia’s youth justice and incarceration system
The Centre for Excellence in Therapeutic Care (CETC) has submitted its response to the Senate Inquiry into Australia’s Youth Justice and Incarceration System. This submission highlights the urgent need for...
Read more
National, unified approach needed to reform youth justice
National, unified approach needed to reform youth justice
The past year has seen alarming regressions across Australia in youth justice policy, with some governments moving towards more punitive measures and stepping back from evidence-based reforms like raising the...
Read more
Help Way Earlier! The 24 recommendations from the Australian Children's Commissioner
Help Way Earlier! The 24 recommendations from the Australian Children's Commissioner
In August 2024, the Australian Children’s Commissioner released the report ‘Help Way Earlier!' How Australia can transform child justice to improve the safety and wellbeing of children. The report investigates...
Read more
What are young people in detention really asking for?
What are young people in detention really asking for?
Young people’s participation in decisions and that affect them is a right, not a privilege. Yet for young people in out-of-home care and detention, this right is often seen as...
Read more